List 'o Ideas

[Taylor]

[Xellos]

[Taylor]

[ZeroJanitor]

I figured they just aren't showing them because they're later-game content

They might be totally done for all we know

[Yavga]

[Taylor]

Just thinking to myself --

I'd like to see a collectible that changes location. Something you cannot just Google and cheat your way to find.

I imagine Playtonic could achieve this by selecting hundreds of places it could be, but making each individual game select one spawn location at random.

Maybe it could reset its location every time you turn the game off too.

Maybe the spawn chance could also be slim, making it almost impossible to find. A bit like a Shiny Pokemon. Though this may be frustrating to people who just want to 100% the game.

[Yavga]

[ReturnRare]

[MrFoogy]

One feature I'd like to see is when you have collected a vast majority of the quills with only a few left (say, 90%) you can get some sort of hint where the rest are so that you don't have to search through every single area again for quills you've missed. It shouldn't show the precise location, of course, but maybe something like a symbol indicating whether or not you are close to any quills.

[kenshiago]

Legitimate fun idea: Remove collision damage on enemies

Now hear me out, I'm not saying make the game easier, just make it so you only take damage from enemies on an enemy attack. The idea of walking into or standing on an enemy if you miss an attack, or just want to jump about is fun. I remember specifically that when I played Kirby's epic yarn I enjoyed the fact that you could just ride a waddle dee around, and enemies only damaged you if they swung something at you. Obviously the enmies would need to be more aggressive to compensate for this, but is's also fun to have that one enemy who wants to defeat you but all it can do is bump into you uselessly.

[lordskelzor]

[Bingo675]

Not sure if this is the place to post this:

I just had a suggestion about utilizing the already functional fixed, overhead camera in more areas, primarily those that require platforming with the threat of death. A perfect example in the Toybox are the two floating blocks that act as a bridge between two of the islands. My first time over there, it was a bit difficult to tell where I was depth-wise (maybe in part due to the absence of textures), and I feel this could be easily alleviated with having the camera be fixed over an area like this. Getting a death because it's difficult to tell where things are is never fun. I think this can also be applied in areas like the stretch around the tower which you roll up, by adding in a fixed camera which rotates with the path (which you guys have done in the past).

Just some suggestions, apologies if they've been mentioned before. The camera is arguably the most important aspect when it comes to navigating 3D space. Loved the Toybox and can't wait to see more from you guys!

[Pegasus37]

I am also unsure if this is the right place to post this, but the one I thought would be the right one is locked, and Bingo675's recent post in this thread was related, so I thought I'd add my two cents here. Let me say that I am really looking forward to this game, the Banjo Kazooie games were great back in the day, and I miss great platformers like these as they seem to be few and far in between anymore. I really enjoyed being able to try things out in the Toybox, and overall it made me more excited for the finished product. That said, I did have issue with the camera, always seeming to think it knew better than I did where I wanted it. Maybe it's just me and/or the way I play, but it felt like when I zoomed out, the camera never stayed zoomed out where I had just put it. When I tried to put the camera on Yooka and Laylee's side, as soon as I started moving, it pivoted back to where it was behind them again, whether I want it to or not. This was especially frustrating in the part where I was trying to roll the big pink ball up the ramp. It took me forever to do this because the camera would rotate back behind them, and then the direction I'm pressing the joystick would be different in relation to the world and thus the way I was going. This resulted in the ball repeatedly falling off the side of the ramp and what I thought should be a relatively quick and easy part of the game took forever! Another place this made things difficult was where you have to roll up the blue ramps that wrap around the yellow hill? mountain? whatever. This was really my only real gripe with the Toybox experience, which I realize is still pre-alpha, but I hope there will be another mode or some way of addressing this in the final product! Otherwise, looks like it's coming along very nicely! Can't wait to see the full game! Keep up the good work there at Playtonic, and please address this camera issue!

[demalmar]

I've got one idea that might come handy in the subject of lives/no lives.

So what's the point of having lives if you can continue playing after that without any problem? Lives were a thing before the save state was possible. Now it does not make any sense. In order to "fix" this, my suggestion goes around a hidden counter for lives that the player cannot access to. Every 10-15 lives (x-x lives), a shortcut scene is shown, where the bad guy makes a "progress" in his master plan, or a joke about it (Grunty&Tooty style). Of course this progress in his plan is not real. It's just a way to make a joke and also to make the player understand losing lives is going against himself.

[Jay]

Here's one that's been on my mind for a little bit now, not sure if anyone has thought this yet or not. I've always loved the way that levels opened up in DK64 with the name of the level in the center and the camera flying towards your starting position while showing a little bit of what's ahead of you. I mean, it's really more of an aesthetic thing and doesn't matter if it's in the game or not, but I always thought it was a nice touch to make that first entrance into a new area a bit more of a bigger deal. What do you think?

[Octopeart]

I like your idea of having an establishing shot of the world when you enter it, provided it's not as obvious as the ones in Super Mario Sunshine. To be fair, the intros were act-specific and were made to show you what to do. It would be good to show off the expanded level areas like this, but that might also defeat the purpose of exploration.


I didn't think this deserved its own thread, so here it is:

I think it's possible there won't be m/any indoor areas in the Tome worlds. Unless it's an intentional edit, the one door we see Yooka and Laylee walk through in the Gamescom footage acts like a portal to another, which is how it worked in the Toybox. Furthermore, we haven't seen any indications of warp pads or anything, but that could be intentional too. I really hope there are some nice ambient indoorsy areas!

[Sgo-J]

How limited do people want the starting moveset to be? A guy on another discussion board said you should only have the jump but I think you should at least have the tail whip and glide ability if not more as soon as you get control of the character

[wacky ducky]

I'd love to see some kind of jukebox in the game that plays crazy songs from outsider artists like Wesley Willis, Harry Merry, Alien Kids and The Shaggs. If the rights turn out to be too expensive, I'd love to hear some really shitty songs by the developers about random subjects like the downsides of putting canned corn on sliced bread. Or maybe you can find those songs on CDs like in Wario Land 4, I love that game

I'd also like to see a character named Trowzer Minnow, referring to a small penis.

Oh, another thing, the Slayer - War Ensemble ukulele cover by Rob Scallon as boss music would be perfect.

[Meinhard1]

Licensed music would maybe be a genre first.
I'd like to see a puppet band inside the Jukebox, as seen in Shining Time Station:

[wacky ducky]

''Licensed music would maybe be a genre first.''
What do you mean by that?

Other random idea: there's some really well hidden button somewhere and if you press it, all characters have butts for faces